Coltrane’s ‘Lost’ 1963 Studio Album Found


On June 29, the Impulse! label will issue previously unreleased studio recordings by John Coltrane (left), Elvin Jones, Jimmy Garrison and McCoy Tyner under the title Both Directions At Once: The Lost Album.

(Photo: © Jim Marshall Photography LLC)

Finding unreleased John Coltrane? Its like discovering buried treasure.

That’s how Ravi Coltrane, the late jazz icon’s saxophone-playing son, feels about the release of Both Directions At Once: The Lost Album (Impulse!). This isn’t an air-check, concert performance or collection of outtakes from existing albums. What we have here are 14 studio performances, all recorded on the same day—March 6, 1963—by famed recording engineer Rudy Van Gelder at his Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, studio, with the classic lineup of Coltrane on tenor and soprano, McCoy Tyner on piano, Jimmy Garrison on bass and Elvin Jones on drums.

Even better, the song selection offers fresh insight into the way that quartet developed and grew. For instance, theres an early, piano-less take on Nature Boythats quite different in character and approach than the version, recorded almost two years later, that would end up on The John Coltrane Quartet Plays.

There are four takes of “Impressions,” each of which is strikingly unique in terms of tempo and approach, with Tyner sitting out on the last two. There are three untitled originals, and not only does the set offer One Up One Downas a studio recording, it gives us two takes of it.

Basically, this is a Coltrane fans fantasy come true.

Both Directions At Once will be released in two versions. One will be a seven-track single disc, with one take each of the tunes Coltrane and company cut that day (Ravi Coltrane and Universal Music’s Ken Druker chose the takes and set the order). There will also be a deluxe edition with a second disc that includes seven alternate takes.

Of course, given how deeply the body of Coltrane recordings has been mined over the last five or six decades, it’s worth wondering how an entire album’s worth got made and then somehow lost. The recording date has been noted in several discographies (although incompletely), and one of the 14 tracks—a lithe, swinging soprano saxophone rendition of a tune from Franz Lehár’s The Merry Widow—turned up as “Vilia” on the 1965 Impulse! anthology The Definitive Jazz Scene, Vol. 3.

Judging from the liner notes (by Ravi Coltrane and Impulse! Records scholar Ashley Khan), these recordings fell between the cracks for three reasons. First, Coltrane and company were back at Van Gelders studio the very next day to record what would become the classic album with singer Johnny Hartman. This was a much more mainstream project and would likely have been seen by the label as a better way to broaden Coltranes appeal than releasing another instrumental quartet album.

Second, Coltrane’s producer at Impulse!, Bob Thiele (1922–’96), was in the habit of recording the saxophonist far more frequently than his label bosses would have liked. I was always over budget with Coltrane,Thiele said in a 1995 interview quoted in the liner notes. I was finally told, You cant just keep recording this guy. Well never get these albums out.Thank God, I did it.

Indeed, if Thiele hadnt followed his instincts, many of the great Coltrane albums that were released after the saxophonists death in 1967—for instance, Sun Ship, First Meditations (For Quartet) or Interstellar Space—would never have existed.

But the third reason the tracks on Both Directions At Once almost disappeared was corporate stinginess and shortsightedness. After Impulse! moved its operations to the West Coast in 1967, the labels collection of master recordings was put into storage. By the early 70s, ABCs fortunes began to wane, and label executives began to institute cost-cutting efficiencies,which included disposing of any stored master tapes for recordings that had never been issued. So the masters from these sessions probably were dumped in the garbage.

Luckily, Rudy Van Gelder also made session tapes—seven-inch mono reels recorded simultaneously with the master tapes—which he gave to the artists. Ravi, whose mother was Alice Coltrane, explained that the source for Both Directions was a tape that had been held by the relatives of Juanita Naima Coltrane (John’s first wife).

Youd finish a record date at Rudy Van Gelders, and he would hand you reel-to-reel tapes for you to review,” Ravi said. “The tapes were in the possession of my fathers first wifes family. We have many session reels ourselves that made it to John and Alices home when they got together. But this is a recording from 63, so my father was still with Naima at the time, and her family held on to several of these tapes.

As to why the album wasnt released before his fathers death, Ravi said that the session may have been intentionally exploratory. The session was recorded the very same week as the Johnny Hartman session, and the band [was about to conclude] a two-week run at Birdland. For me it did feel like, OK, well, were doing a few sessions this week. One of them will maybe get the band warmed up, so why dont we lay down some of the things we have been performing at Birdland all week? It does feel very much like a live set recorded in a studio.

Part of that may be the amount of space these tracks give Garrison and Jones. For instance, the album-opening Untitled Original 11383Take 1features a rare, driving arco solo by Garrison, while Nature Boyrelies heavily on the way Jonesshuffling polyrhythms contrast against Garrisons repeated use of a syncopated anchor based on two dotted quarter notes followed by a quarter note. The two takes of One Up One Downboth notably feature a shout chorus with Jones.

You do get to hear the role of the rhythm section a little bit differently,” Ravi said. “Theres lots of drum solos. Theres lots of bass solos. Again, it does take on the character of a live performance.

On a more conventional session, such as the one with Hartman, there would be less space for the rhythm section to stretch out or show off. On those record dates, the arrangements were very, very tight, and if there were any solos at all, it was going to be a saxophone solo and a piano solo,he added. But on this record, you get a chance to hear the rhythm section really, really interact. Lots of great moments between Elvin and Jimmy Garrison, for sure.

Above all, Both Directions At Once works as a snapshot of a great band on the cusp of revolution. There are elements of the performance that do hark back to John Coltranes early days as a blues player and a bebop player, Ravi said, pointing to “Vilia” and the 11-minute “Slow Blues.But there is also material like One Up One Down,which, he says, is leaning toward the music that John and the quartet eventually get to, in 1964 and 65, playing more of these open structures. So its kind of a rare glimpse, to see John with one foot in the past, and one foot in the future.” DB

  • web_Ce%CC%81cile_Mclorin_Salvant_2019_New_Orleans_0692_credit_Adam_McCullough.JPG

    Cécile McLorin Salvant performs at the New Orleans Jazz & Heritage Festival on May 3.

  • piano_francies_creditJatiLindsay.jpg

    James Francies arranged a version of Rufus’ “Ain’t Nobody” for his debut album, which was met with approval from the song’s original singer, Chaka Khan.

  • RonCarter_byMarkLeeBlackshear.jpg

    Ron Carter’s recording with poet Danny Simmons, The Brown Beatnik Tomes (Live At BRIC House), is the bassist’s latest collaboration with someone from outside the world of jazz.

  • Jimmie_Vaughn-4915_credit_%C2%A9MarkSheldon.jpg

    Jimmie Vaughan interprets songs by Lloyd Price and Clarence “Gatemouth” Brown on his new album, Baby, Please Come Home.

  • AnatTenet_creditStevenSussman.jpg

    Anat Cohen’s long musical relationship with Oded Lev-Ari has resulted in “Triple Helix: Concerto For Clarinet And Ensemble,” which premiered in January at Carnegie Hall.

On Sale Now
September 2019
James Carter
Look Inside
Print | Digital | iPad