Jun 3, 2025 11:25 AM
In Memoriam: Al Foster, 1943–2025
Al Foster, a drummer regarded for his fluency across the bebop, post-bop and funk/fusion lineages of jazz, died May 28…
Nicholas Payton looked very zen in this photo used for a feature in the January 2024 edition of DownBeat. His departure from Berklee College of Music was anything but.
(Photo: Dana Distortion)We live in divisive times. Earlier this year, we learned that the gifted composer, bandleader and trumpeter Nicholas Payton was fired from his gig as the brass department chair at Berklee College of Music after two conservative media outlets wrote scathing articles about Payton’s perceived anti-Semitic remarks about Jews.
If you’d like to look them up, feel free to go online and search Nicholas Payton, Jews and anti-Semitic. You’ll find the articles and plenty of social media chatter. We’re not giving it the space here.
At the same time, Payton started a beef on social media with pianist Connie Han. He reposted a former bandmate’s trash talk about the pianist not being able to swing and worse, presumably because she’s Asian and a woman. It was part of a back and forth between the two artists with Han saying Payton “does not deserve his position at Berklee.”
All of this led to a petition on change.org demanding Payton’s dismissal from Berklee. At one point, we learned that the petition had more than 5,000 signatures.
Well, he was fired in mid-April after getting promoted in the fall of 2024. One thing to note, he made plenty of inflamatory online comments that pre-date his promotion. That’s how Nicholas Payton rolls. And beefs and brashness are not uncommon in jazz history (or Black American Music as Payton has rebranded his work).
Did Payton cross the line? I think so. But I’m an old white guy who married a Jewish girl and raised his daughter in the faith. Take what I say with a grain of kosher salt.
Should he have lost his gig? I don’t know. Maybe there’s more to this than has come out. But I’d like to say no. At an institution of higher learning, where the marketplace of ideas should be championed, this could have been a teaching moment. What if there was an opportunity for deep discussion and debate? How about a series of discussions in front of an audience of students and faculty? After all, Nick Payton is not alone in his viewpoints. It would be interesting and instructive to hear where he’s coming from. Bring in other viewpoints, including Connie Han, to hear where they are coming from, too. It’s an opportunity to separate fact from fiction, a chance to learn, maybe even change some minds.
While all this was going on, DownBeat had scheduled a feature on Terri Lyne Carrington and Christie Dashiell’s reimagination of Max Roach’s classic, 1960 protest album We Insist! That feature about We Insist 2025! appears on page 30 of our July 2025 issue.
Here’s the rub. Carrington also teaches at Berklee and led the founding of the Berklee Institute of Jazz and Gender Justice back in 2018. As we know, diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives such as this are under attack as well. She has concerns about the safety and future of this vital organization in the current political climate.
It’s a bit ironic. At a glance, you’d think these two would be on opposite sides of a very tall fence. But here they were, working at the same institution. Payton has been featured with Carrington’s band Social Science. He played on Carrington’s Grammy-winning New Standards Vol. 1.
People and situations aren’t easily explained on social media. It’s easy to be provacative hiding behind a cell phone. It’s easy to cancel viewpoints you don’t agree with. It’s damned hard to have real conversations and come to mutual understanding in our very complex world. DB
Foster was truly a drummer to the stars, including Miles Davis, Sonny Rollins and Joe Henderson.
Jun 3, 2025 11:25 AM
Al Foster, a drummer regarded for his fluency across the bebop, post-bop and funk/fusion lineages of jazz, died May 28…
Benny Benack III and his quartet took the Midwest Jazz Collective’s route for a test run this spring.
Jun 3, 2025 10:31 AM
The time and labor required to tour is, for many musicians, daunting at best and prohibitive at worst. It’s hardly…
To record Dream Manifest (Dom Recs), Croker convened artists from his current and recent past ensembles, plus special guests.
Jun 10, 2025 4:13 PM
Partway through his early set at Smoke Jazz Club, Theo Croker blinks the room back into focus. He leans over the piano.…
“There’s nothing quite like it,” Springs says of working with an orchestra. “It’s 60 people working in harmony in the moment. Singing with them is kind of empowering but also humbling at the same time.”
Jun 17, 2025 11:12 AM
When it came time to pose for the cover of her new album, Lady In Satin — a tribute to Billie Holiday’s 1958…
James Brandon Lewis earned honors for Artist of the Year and Tenor Saxophonist of the Year. Three of his recordings placed in the Albums of the Year category.
Jul 17, 2025 12:44 PM
You see before you what we believe is the largest and most comprehensive Critics Poll in the history of jazz. DownBeat…
