Jul 17, 2025 12:44 PM
DownBeat’s 73rd Annual Critics Poll: One for the Record Books
You see before you what we believe is the largest and most comprehensive Critics Poll in the history of jazz. DownBeat…
Ken Vandermark (Photo: Michael Jackson)
(Photo: )With standout performances by Roy Haynes, Ken Vandermark, Ambrose Akinmusire and Allen Toussaint, the 2012 Chicago Jazz Festival on Aug. 30–Sept. 2 was a meticulously designed program that encompassed a wide range of jazz styles. Despite some moments of inclement weather, the proceedings were executed with very few pitfalls.
Festivities kicked off on Aug. 30 with a Stu Katz and Willie Pickens duo performance followed by a rather predictable Ella Fitzgerald tribute by Jeff Lindberg’s Chicago Jazz Orchestra. But it was 87-year-old drummer Haynes, who danced jovially against the backdrop of his Fountain of Youth Band on Aug. 31, that sent the Pritzker Pavilion in Millennium Park into a frenzy. Despite a long Q&A session that distracted from his set, Haynes proved to be a seasoned showman who knows how to communicate with his audience on multiple levels.
Prior to Haynes appearance, audiences were treated to a tasteful tribute to a hometown hero, saxophonist Von Freeman, who died Aug. 11 at age 88. The heartfelt musical accolade, led by Freeman’s saxophonist son Chico, was a stark contrast to the sweltering showcase by the Chicago Afro Latin Jazz Ensemble, which set fire to the brisk night air with dramatic syncopations, versatile rhythmic prowess and first-class instrumental artistry.
From the witty repartee of Matt Wilson’s Arts & Crafts (featuring trumpeter Randy Brecker) to the mathematical countermelodies of Steve Coleman and Five Elements, the festival offered plenty of highlights. One could easily hear threads of Akinmusire’s highly emotive 2011 Blue Note debut, When The Heart Emerges Glistening, during the trumpeter’s afternoon performance on the Jazz on Jackson stage. Akinmusire stretched and extended the tone of his horn, from intimate muting to arena-worthy trills. Understated tenorist Walter Smith III breezed effortlessly under the radar and into the mix amid the no-frills brushwork and cross-sticking of drummer Justin Brown. The quintet offered a solo spotlight to pianist Sam Harris, who contributed some unexpected 88-key theatrics.
Vandermark, the festival’s artist-in-residence, played in two extremely different settings—with the 11-piece Resonance Ensemble and in a duo with tenorist Joe McPhee—on Saturday evening (Sept. 1) and Sunday afternoon (Sept. 2), respectively. But whether it was the highly layered compositions of the Krakow cohort, for whom the multi-reedist wrote new material, or his engaging musical conversations with McPhee, Vandermark retained the Chicago-informed free improvisational style that has become his signature.
Toussaint concluded the festival with an exuberant celebration on Sunday night. An architect of New Orleans r&b, he demonstrated his deep affinity for early jazz on the 2009 disc The Bright Mississippi (Nonesuch), which was the focus of this set. As on the disc, clarinetist Don Byron and guitarist Marc Ribot proved ideal partners for Toussaint’s rolling piano lines and classically informed stride. Byron’s short phrases contrasted with Toussaint’s extravagance, but their shared sense of swing brought them together on “St. James Infirmary.” Playing acoustic, Ribot conjured Django Reinhardt on a stirring version of “Solitude,” coaxing lovely trills from the pianist. Toussaint didn’t abandon his own soul legacy, offering rousing renditions of classics like “Southern Nights” and “Everything I Do Gonh Be Funky (From Now On).” A man of impeccable class, Toussaint ended with a shout-out to Chicago piano great Pickens.
On the same Labor Day weekend, other jazz aficionados headed to Motor City for the Detroit Jazz Festival, which DownBeat also covered.
—Hilary Brown James Brandon Lewis earned honors for Artist of the Year and Tenor Saxophonist of the Year. Three of his recordings placed in the Albums of the Year category. Jul 17, 2025 12:44 PM You see before you what we believe is the largest and most comprehensive Critics Poll in the history of jazz. DownBeat… Galper was often regarded as an underrated master of his craft. Jul 22, 2025 10:58 AM Hal Galper, a pianist, composer and arranger who enjoyed a substantial performing career but made perhaps a deeper… Chuck Mangione on the cover of the May 8, 1975, edition of DownBeat. Jul 29, 2025 1:00 PM Chuck Mangione, one of the most popular trumpeters in jazz history, passed away on July 24 at home in Rochester, New… “Hamiet was one of the most underrated musicians ever,” says Whitaker of baritone saxophonist Hamiet Bluiett. Jul 8, 2025 7:30 AM At 56, Rodney Whitaker, professor of jazz bass and director of jazz studies at Michigan State University, is equally… Jul 17, 2025 11:35 AM The DownBeat Critics Poll provides a wonderful snapshot of the jazz scene today, with much to explore and many great…
In other news... DownBeat's Most Read Stories
DownBeat’s 73rd Annual Critics Poll: One for the Record Books
Pianist, Educator Hal Galper Dies at 87
Chuck Mangione, Rest in Peace
Blindfold Test: Rodney Whitaker
Complete Critics Poll Results!
