Shuffle Along Revives Legacy of Black Broadway Pioneers

  I  
Image

Joshua Henry, Brandon Victor Dixon, Billy Porter and Brian Stokes Mitchell, with Richard Riaz Yoder, in a scene from Shuffle Along.

(Photo: Julieta Cervantes)

Between the passages of exposition—which check off the facts with academic precision—35 musical numbers set the narrative on fire with the kind of jazz-a-matazz that lifts audience members out of their seats.

Though it preserves the broad period rhythms of old Broadway and most of the original score—and adds Blake’s most famous ballad, “Memories Of You,” in a show-stopping performance by Broadway superstar Audra McDonald—the election tale itself is reduced to a bullet point inside the larger story.

Essentially, the new Shuffle Along sits on the most ancient show biz conceit of all—the “let’s put on a show” formula that Mickey Rooney and Judy Garland spun into mocking self-parody decades ago. But as a show with an entirely African-American cast, the play dealt with problems that Mickey and Judy never had to face. And therein lies the stuff of the new Shuffle Along.

George C. Wolfe’s sentimental book and Savion Glover’s spectacular tap ensembles could have rubbed our noses in a bill of Jim Crow indictments. But their intent is not to shame the audience with a procession of past outrages, all of which are acknowledged but not prosecuted. Instead, the statute of limitations has thawed outrage into laughter.

In the first act, a white power broker explains, “Everybody knows with colored shows—You know how it goes,” meaning that theater companies do best by “playing black” for the white folks. He pauses for a beat, stares through the fourth wall, and invites the nearly all-white Music Box audience to laugh at itself.

For one telling second, the protective 95-year safety gap between then and now dissolves. But there is no meanness in the gesture, only the bonding amity of a mutual self-awareness. It’s a quality that Wolfe and Glover (who joined the performing cast of the show this summer) brought to their last Broadway collaboration, Bring in da Noise, Bring in da Funk in 1996.

Then there is the denouement, the final roll call of who and what Shuffle Along bequeathed to black theater and music. Names such as William Grant Still, Josephine Baker, Hall Johnson and Paul Robeson may be only dimly remembered today. But three of the show’s alumnae would figure in Duke Ellington’s early career. Fredi Washington co-stared in Ellington’s first film, Black and Tan Fantasy (1929), while Adelaide Hall performed the wordless vocal on the original “Creole Love Call.” And Florence Mills, who died in 1927, became the inspiration for Ellington’s famous composition “Black Beauty.”

As for Eubie Blake, he lived long enough to be rediscovered by John Hammond in 1969, enjoyed late-career fame that included a 1978 Broadway hit (Eubie!), and died in 1983 at age 96, the final link of living memory to the original production.

But in the end, the legend of Shuffle Along pours into the larger history that became the Harlem Renaissance. It broke the ground that led to a bigger place. Accordingly, it bears the ultimate prerequisite of immortality. That’s what the new Shuffle Along reminds us about the old one.

Page 2 of 2   < 1 2


  • Jack_DeJohnette_by_Steve_Sussman.jpg

    ​Jack DeJohnette boasted a musical resume that was as long as it was fearsome.

  • KurtElling_6.2.25_by_ElliotMandel-REV-6.jpg

    “Think of all the creative people I’m going to meet and a whole other way of thinking about music and a challenge of singing completely different material than I would have sung otherwise to my highest level in dedication to the moment,” Elling says about his Broadway run.

  • Pat_Metheny_Side-Eye_III_Jimmy_Katz.jpg

    Pat Metheny will perform with his Side-Eye III ensemble at ​Big Ears 2026 in Knoxville, Tennessee, next March.

  • Courtesy_Bobby_Bradford_GoFundMe_page.jpg

    “[That’s] the thing of the beboppers,” Bradford said. “These guys were important for not only playing that wonderful music, but they knew a sort of social stance, you see?”

    Bobby Bradford: Phoenix Rising

    It was a calm, balmy, near-perfect evening in Westwood, California, not far from UCLA, in the expansive courtyard at…

  • Esperanza_Spalding_3825_5x7.jpeg

    ​Esperanza Spalding closed an audacious Chicago Jazz Festival set with “Endangered Species.”


On Sale Now
November 2025
Gary Bartz
Look Inside
Subscribe
Print | Digital | iPad