Jul 17, 2025 12:44 PM
DownBeat’s 73rd Annual Critics Poll: One for the Record Books
You see before you what we believe is the largest and most comprehensive Critics Poll in the history of jazz. DownBeat…
Top row from left: Nduduzo Makhathini (Photo: Nailah Makhathini); Brandee Younger and Dezron Douglas at their home in the East Harlem neighborhood of New York City (Photo: Courtesy of Artists); Chick Corea (Photo: Toshi Sakurai, Courtesy Chick Corea Productions). Bottom row from left: Christian McBride (Photo: R. Andrew Lepley); Stanton Moore at his home in New Orleans (Photo: Lauren Del Rio); Wolfgang Muthspiel and his 4-year-old daughter, Flora, at their home in Vienna (Photo: Courtesy of Artist); Kris Davis (Photo: ©Caroline Mardok).
(Photo: DownBeat Collage)“There is definitely gonna be space for alternatives,” Makhathini said. “So, all of these efforts that we’re seeing on social media, it’s definitely something that we can keep going [after the pandemic]. We’ll reimagine the field—‘the field’ meaning the bandstand. There is a particular way in which human beings imagine gathering; there are different registers of how people gather.”
Along with a reassessment of public spaces, the pianist also foresees a realignment of our interior lives and an adjustment in how performers rely on previously established industry norms.
“There is going to be a shift in terms of how people engage the artist after this—and there’s gonna be new relationships with audiences after this,” Makhathini said. “What we have now as an alternative plan will stay as a parallel sort of reality for artists. People are going to be consciously regarding the online [approach] as an option. So, for instance, there’s gonna be people playing stuff from studios and broadcasting from a studio. When I do my next record, I would love to broadcast the session.”
That idea might have seemed revelatory a few years ago—but it could become the norm after the pandemic. An antecedent arrived in 2017, when bassist and vocalist Esperanza Spalding opened up her life to fans while working on Exposure, streaming 77 hours in the studio and emerging with a recording that displayed not just her musical prowess, but also a meta train-of-thought beyond what most musicians were brash enough to attempt.
Becoming stars of their own movies might not actually be a huge leap for some musicians, though. Most already have at least some experience booking gigs, running bands, arranging recordings and negotiating with everyone from label executives to talent agents and publicists. Livestreaming from the studio would only add one more aspect to their careers, and Makhathini believes the creative set contains multitudes.
“[There] is absolutely no differentiation between being a healer, being an artist, being a dancer, being a diviner—all of these things,” Makhathini said. “There is a kind of totality in them.”
As venues, labels and independent performers scramble to find reliable sources of revenue, it still might be too early to envision some grand structural reorganization in jazz that will prove workable after musicians and fans can safely congregate again. But for now, the loss of gigs, studio sessions and teaching opportunities has forced a reckoning with who we are as individuals and as a society, and who and what we value most.
What we think of as the life of a musician could be profoundly different by 2021.
“We already had to have a lot of skills before—but these are extra skills that we have to learn,” Younger said while discussing the outsized role of livestreams in the current jazz ecosystem.
Douglas noted that negotiating the pandemic should prompt musicians to develop some sort of plan for becoming more self-reliant and visible after the world returns to semi-normalcy.
“I have a hustler’s mentality, so whatever [the scene] is going to be, I’m going to be involved in it,” the bassist said, confidently. “Whether the scene, whether my peers, whether they like it or not—they don’t have to. That’s the beauty of art: You don’t have to appreciate everyone’s art. But you can’t deny it.” DB
This story originally was published in the July 2020 issue of DownBeat.
James Brandon Lewis earned honors for Artist of the Year and Tenor Saxophonist of the Year. Three of his recordings placed in the Albums of the Year category.
Jul 17, 2025 12:44 PM
You see before you what we believe is the largest and most comprehensive Critics Poll in the history of jazz. DownBeat…
Galper was often regarded as an underrated master of his craft.
Jul 22, 2025 10:58 AM
Hal Galper, a pianist, composer and arranger who enjoyed a substantial performing career but made perhaps a deeper…
Chuck Mangione on the cover of the May 8, 1975, edition of DownBeat.
Jul 29, 2025 1:00 PM
Chuck Mangione, one of the most popular trumpeters in jazz history, passed away on July 24 at home in Rochester, New…
“Hamiet was one of the most underrated musicians ever,” says Whitaker of baritone saxophonist Hamiet Bluiett.
Jul 8, 2025 7:30 AM
At 56, Rodney Whitaker, professor of jazz bass and director of jazz studies at Michigan State University, is equally…
Jul 17, 2025 11:35 AM
The DownBeat Critics Poll provides a wonderful snapshot of the jazz scene today, with much to explore and many great…