Jul 17, 2025 12:44 PM
DownBeat’s 73rd Annual Critics Poll: One for the Record Books
You see before you what we believe is the largest and most comprehensive Critics Poll in the history of jazz. DownBeat…
Composer, multi-instrumentalist and bandleader Gordon Goodwin knows that accolades can’t make his music better or worse.
(Photo: Joe Meyer)Axt, preferring a sportier analogy, said, “The Big Phat Band is like a Ferrari: It’s capable of doing a lot of things really well.”
As for Goodwin, the man with two Hondas in his garage, ruminating about luxury vehicles could strike a nerve. “Do you know what kind of car I’d be driving if I didn’t spend $75,000 on a record?” he asked, incredulously. “How many vacations did we miss? I was lucky that my family was supportive.”
He paused to reflect.
“Having said all that, there are reasons to do things besides money, and that’s of course why I’m doing this.”
The numerous awards he has received provide only so much motivation. The four-time Grammy winner recalled what he said to an interviewer after one of his triumphs: “As good as this feels to my ego, I know that this Grammy doesn’t make my music any better. Just as there are four guys out there who just lost, that doesn’t make their music any worse.”
A theme all the instrumentalists kept coming back to was how the Phat Band represents for them a chance to reclaim the music as a labor of love, a meaningful shared experience that transcends the workman-like industry model they have entered into (and profited from). “It’s like if you were a sous-chef in a restaurant,” Marienthal suggested, “and you just respect the head chef so much that you want to work as hard as it takes to make sure that the dream of a leader is realized. That’s how we feel about Gordon.”
Goodwin recognizes their loyalty in the context of fulfilling his dreams. “I am amazed by the chances I’ve had ... and the life I’ve been able to lead,” he said. “I’m stumbling as I say these words because it feels like I’m just getting started. I hope that I always feel that way. That’s how you stay alive and relevant.
“Music has been my driving force since I was very young. I know that whatever else is going on—on my worst day, I still get to write music—and what’s better than that? What’s better than having a kid come up and tell me, ‘I listened to the Phat Band, and it inspired me so much I want to learn music.’ What’s better than that? Is a Grammy better than that? I don’t think so.” DB
James Brandon Lewis earned honors for Artist of the Year and Tenor Saxophonist of the Year. Three of his recordings placed in the Albums of the Year category.
Jul 17, 2025 12:44 PM
You see before you what we believe is the largest and most comprehensive Critics Poll in the history of jazz. DownBeat…
Galper was often regarded as an underrated master of his craft.
Jul 22, 2025 10:58 AM
Hal Galper, a pianist, composer and arranger who enjoyed a substantial performing career but made perhaps a deeper…
Chuck Mangione on the cover of the May 8, 1975, edition of DownBeat.
Jul 29, 2025 1:00 PM
Chuck Mangione, one of the most popular trumpeters in jazz history, passed away on July 24 at home in Rochester, New…
“Hamiet was one of the most underrated musicians ever,” says Whitaker of baritone saxophonist Hamiet Bluiett.
Jul 8, 2025 7:30 AM
At 56, Rodney Whitaker, professor of jazz bass and director of jazz studies at Michigan State University, is equally…
Jul 17, 2025 11:35 AM
The DownBeat Critics Poll provides a wonderful snapshot of the jazz scene today, with much to explore and many great…